• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Jolly Pumpkin - Old Mission Peninsula

Located on the picturesque Old Mission Peninsula in Traverse City, Michigan, Jolly Pumpkin offers a cozy, rustic atmosphere with a diverse menu of desserts, American cuisine, and a full bar featuring a wide selection of beers. The establishment prides itself on its unique concept and local charm, housed in what appears to be an old horse barn. With options like the Wagyu burger, pumpkin dessert, and flavorful pizzas, paired with exceptional service and stunning sunset views, Jolly Pumpkin is a hidden gem for those seeking a laid-back dining experience with a touch of Midwest charm.

Jolly Pumpkin - Old Mission Peninsula: Reviews & Ratings

Marin C.
Marin C.

I visited for happy hour. I tried a bee well plum cider, great. I had coffee and Kahlua, too. Any mixed drinks, spirits, I can only drink half- too much of a lightweight. I had a chicken tinga taco, tasty. It has black beans, shredded chicken and came with a ranch flavored sour cream and a kinda smokey sweet salsa. I usually don't like sour cream, but I am all about anything ranch-flavored. How Midwest of me, I know. I ordered a pepperoni pizza to go, a coworker had recommended their pizza. You can't do a custom one, but there were enough types to chose from. Pepperoni for dad, and I picked off the pepperoni at home(picky eater is me).

Sarah R.
Sarah R.

This place had the old, rustic, log cabin in the woods vibe. It was kind of dark and wooded. Could use a little bit of light and cleaning... But it felt so cozy and relaxed. The bartender was super knowledgeable and accommodating. We tried a flight of beer and also some samples and loved them all. They had a huge variety. We got the nachos and they were piled high with all the fixings. Our favorite tho was the pumpkin dessert- it was like a mix between pumpkin roll, pie, and like a stuffed donut.

Patrick S.
Patrick S.

Hidden gem out on the peninsula! Built out of what looks like an old horse barn, this is a concept run by a local group with many unique brands. Full bar with lots of beers. Locals have their own mugs marked and hanging from the rafters. Bar seating. High tops. Four and six tops make for larger group configurations. Service was spot on. Everything we had for dinner was very tasty and served quickly. Burger, wedge salad, mushroom pizza and cherryade were all amazing. The Wagyu burger was top notch. I almost forgot, the pumpkin cake was stellar. Highly recommended. Food was so good I forgot to take pictures. Definitely a repeat for future visits.

Tabitha C.
Tabitha C.

Incredible sunset view, great pizza and beer. Plenty of yard for kids to play while they wait for food.

Stephen L.
Stephen L.

Great beer, first off. The food didnt disappoint either. Wagyu burger was great! Our server was very knowledgeable and polite. The vibe is a calm, relaxing one.

Lily S.
Lily S.

Food: It was just good nothing spectacular! We got pizza, fries & a sandwich. Service: Staff was friendly and kind but we arrived at 6:40 and were told there would be an hour & 15 min wait (they close at 8 but said we would still be served.) We were actually seated around 7:25. I would recommend coming for lunch or a very early dinner. The staff was tired from a long day and very slow. We didn't get silverware or napkins and had to go find someone to ask. Atmosphere: Amazing setting and views. The inside was very cool. I wish they had music playing or something to set the vibes a little more but overall good. Again, I think earlier in the day it might be more lively. Overall, a beautiful place to stop but would recommend only going during the day!

Erin P.
Erin P.

Jolly Pumpkin was ABSOLUTELY wonderful! We visited here with some friends from college and were very pleasantly surprised with the delicious selection of beers. I had their sour and it was tasty, and the food was equally as good. Our waitress was also kind and attentive. I'd highly recommend visiting here!

Hannah H.
Hannah H.

Aw man the pizza here was BOMB! We had a classic pepperoni pie and were in love. That crust is *chefs kiss.* We also had their Cheddar Ale Soup which really hit the spot. I had the La Roja sour which was pretty good! Our server was great and when they didn't have the sour I'd originally asked for, he brought out a few samples to try of some other options which I really appreciated. We'd definitely come back for another pizza when back in town!

Location

Introducing Jolly Pumpkin - Old Mission Peninsula

Located on 13512 Peninsula Dr in Traverse City, MI, Jolly Pumpkin - Old Mission Peninsula is a hidden gem known for its cozy and relaxed atmosphere. The restaurant offers a unique blend of desserts, American cuisine, and a wide selection of beverages, making it a popular spot for locals and visitors alike.

One of the standout features of Jolly Pumpkin is its extensive utilities, including options for reservation, delivery, takeout, and even catering services. The restaurant caters to a diverse range of dietary preferences with vegan options available and a menu that is sure to satisfy all taste buds.

Customers rave about the flavorful dishes served at Jolly Pumpkin, with highlights like the chicken tinga taco, pepperoni pizza, and wagyu burger receiving high praise. The pumpkin dessert, described as a mix between a pumpkin roll and a stuffed donut, is a must-try for those with a sweet tooth.

Pair your meal with one of the many beers or spirits available at the full bar and enjoy the calming ambiance of the restaurant. Whether you're looking for a casual lunch, a group dinner, or a relaxing evening out, Jolly Pumpkin - Old Mission Peninsula is sure to impress.

Don't miss out on the opportunity to experience this unique dining destination in Traverse City. Make a reservation, grab a seat at the bar, and indulge in the delicious flavors that Jolly Pumpkin has to offer.